Print This Page Print    Email to a Friend Email

Sugary Drinks, 'Bad' Carbs Tied to Breast, Prostate Cancers

Preliminary study finds more reason to improve your diet

By Amy Norton
HealthDay Reporter

TUESDAY, April 5, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- People who consume a lot of processed carbohydrates -- think snack foods and sweets -- and sugary drinks may face heightened risks of breast and prostate cancers, a new study suggests.

Researchers said the study, reported Tuesday at the American Society for Nutrition annual meeting in San Diego, does not prove that "bad" carbs cause cancer.

But given that breast and prostate cancers are two of the most common cancers in the United States, the connection gives more reason for people to cut processed foods from their diets, said lead researcher Nour Makarem.

"The carbohydrate quality of your diet matters for a number of reasons," said Makarem, a Ph.D. candidate in nutrition at New York University.

In general, health experts already recommend limiting sugary drinks and processed carbohydrates, and eating more fruits, vegetables, legumes, fiber-rich whole grains and "good" unsaturated fats.

So the new findings -- considered preliminary until published in a peer-reviewed medical journal -- add more weight to that advice, Makarem said.

She pointed, in particular, to the link her team found between sugar-sweetened drinks (both soda and fruit juice) and prostate cancer risk. Compared with men who never drank sugary beverages, those who had them a few times a week showed more than triple the risk of developing prostate cancer.

And that was with other factors -- including obesity, smoking and other diet habits -- taken into account, Makarem said.

Still, it is difficult to weed out the effects of particular diet habits on cancer risk, said Marji McCullough, strategic director of nutritional epidemiology for the American Cancer Society.

"Few dietary factors apart from alcohol and/or obesity have been consistently related to postmenopausal breast cancer and prostate cancer," McCullough said.

The question of whether carbohydrate quality affects cancer risk -- independent of obesity -- is important, according to McCullough. But it's also a "challenging" one to answer, she said.

The new findings are based on nearly 3,200 U.S. adults whose diet habits and cancer rates were tracked for more than 20 years. During that time, 565 people were diagnosed with cancer.

At first glance, higher carb intake was tied to a lower risk of breast cancer. But the picture changed when carb quality was considered, Makarem noted.

She said that women whose diets emphasized healthy carbs -- vegetables, fruit, whole grains and legumes -- were 67 percent less likely to develop breast cancer, compared to women who favored refined carbs. Refined carbs include many baked goods, white bread and white potatoes.

When it came to prostate cancer risk, men who regularly drank sugary juices or soda were more than three times as likely to develop disease versus men who steered clear of those drinks, the findings showed.

That does not prove sweet drinks directly contribute to prostate cancer, Makarem acknowledged. Still, she said, many studies have implicated the beverages in the risks of obesity and type 2 diabetes -- so there are other reasons to cut back.

"Plus," Makarem said, "it's an easy change to make in your diet."

The American Beverage Association took issue with the findings.

"The authors of this study abstract acknowledge their findings do not show that beverages cause any disease," the group said in a statement. "Moreover, the study was limited to one demographic group that is not reflective of the population of the United States." (Most study participants were white.)

The beverage association also said that the American Cancer Society cites multiple potential risk factors for breast, prostate and colon cancer, so singling out diet is difficult. The group also said that because the study hasn't been published in a peer-reviewed journal, "very few study details are available" and it's therefore tough to draw firm conclusions.

Sugary drinks weren't the only diet factor that mattered, though, according to the researchers. Prostate cancer risk was also heightened among men whose diets were generally high in "glycemic load" -- which, Makarem said, basically means they ate a lot of refined carbs.

The study also implicated "processed lunch foods," including pizza, deli meats and burgers. Men who ate those foods four or more times a week were twice as likely to develop prostate cancer, compared to men who had them no more than once a week, the researchers found.

According to McCullough, it's hard to know whether certain foods, per se, contribute to breast or prostate cancers -- or whether, for example, it's overall calorie intake and weight gain that are the true culprits.

But the bottom line, Makarem said, is that whole, "high-quality" foods are a generally healthier choice than processed ones.

More information

The American Cancer Society has more on diet and cancer risk.

SOURCES: Nour Makarem, Ph.D. student, nutrition, New York University, New York City; Marji McCullough, Sc.D., R.D., strategic director, nutritional epidemiology, American Cancer Society, Atlanta; America Beverage Association, statement, April 5, 2016; abstract, April 5, 2016, presentation, American Society for Nutrition's Experimental Biology meeting, San Diego

Copyright © 2016 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

465 Congress Street Suite 600 | Portland, Maine 04101-3537 | (207) 775-7001