Parental Debt May Affect Kids' Behavior
The key seems to be the reasons why they borrow, study suggests
By Alan Mozes
THURSDAY, Jan. 21, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- The type of debt parents accrue might affect their child's behavior -- for better or worse, new research suggests.
Mortgages fall in the plus column, meaning they're positively linked to a child's emotional well-being. But, unpaid credit card bills appear to occupy the negative side, associated with more behavioral problems in kids, researchers determined.
Study co-author Jason Houle said the findings suggest that borrowing money can be a "double-edged sword" for parents and children alike, having "both positive and negative consequences depending on what it's being used for."
Houle, an assistant professor of sociology at Dartmouth College in Hanover, N.H., said it stands to reason that debt taken on to better your life -- say, a college loan or a mortgage to buy a home in a safer neighborhood -- might lead to better outcomes in children. On the other hand, he said, mounting debt linked to high-interest credit cards and short-term investments might indicate economic distress and thus be more harmful.
Houle and co-author Lawrence Berger, a professor at the School of Social Work at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, analyzed data from two U.S. studies, which together tracked more than 9,000 mothers and their children ages 5 to 14 between 1986 and 2008.
Debt was characterized as total parent debt: mortgages; student loans; auto loans; and "unsecured debt," meaning money owed to credit cards, businesses, individuals, banks (aside from mortgages), and/or medical bills.
Debt information was then compared to reports from mothers on their children's behavior either every year or every other year.
Overall, children whose parents held some debt displayed greater social and emotional well-being than those whose parents had no debt whatsoever. Having debt was more common among parents who were white, American-born, better educated, or married, probably because they had greater ability to borrow in the first place, the researchers noted.
That said, the research team found that those who had more overall debt (regardless of debt type) were more likely to have children with behavior issues than those who had less overall debt.
But digging deeper, the co-authors saw that the largest driver behind that behavior association was unsecured debt, such as unpaid credit card bills.
And children of parents who held some type of unsecured debt were significantly more likely to struggle behaviorally than children of parents who didn't have such debt.
By contrast, children of parents with mortgages and/or educational debt appeared to face a diminished risk for childhood behavior problems, although the study authors said more research is needed to confirm the finding.
The reason? Houle and Berger said unsecured debt may foster parental stress and/or anxiety. That, in turn, might negatively affect (or reflect) parental behavior, which ultimately worsens prospects for childhood development and well-being.
However, parents with piles of bills shouldn't fear their kids are doomed to act out. For one thing, the study findings don't prove a direct cause-and-effect relationship between debt and childhood misbehavior.
Houle suggested that the problem is likely a broad societal issue, rather than the function of individual parental irresponsibility.
"As a sociologist I'm not ready to leave this entirely at the feet of the borrowers," he said.
For many, debt "is the only choice they have" in the face of stagnating wages and abundant credit, he said.
The study findings were published online Jan. 21 in the journal Pediatrics.
Nadine Kaslow, a professor in the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta, described the study as "really important, if not surprising."
"It makes sense that the type of debt you have makes a difference," said Kaslow, former president of the American Psychological Association. "And financial stress related to relatively risky spending moves, like credit card debt, is likely to be higher than stress related to more normative spending, like buying a house."
Kaslow said the stress of credit card debt, perhaps along with the generally riskier lifestyle of parents who take on that type of debt, can trickle down to the children.
"It can be tough on parents," she said, "but it can also be tough on kids."
There's more on childhood and teenage stress at the American Psychological Association.
SOURCES: Jason N. Houle, Ph.D., assistant professor, sociology, Dartmouth College, Hanover, N.H.; Nadine Kaslow, Ph.D., former president, American Psychological Association, and professor and vice chair, department of psychiatry, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta; Jan. 21, 2016, Pediatrics, online
Copyright © 2016 HealthDay. All rights reserved.
465 Congress Street Suite 600 | Portland, Maine 04101-3537 | (207) 775-7001